How to configure "Signing Order" for parallel and sequential mixed workflows?

Understanding Signing Order in eSignature Workflows

In the realm of electronic signatures, configuring the “Signing Order” is a critical feature for managing document workflows efficiently. This capability allows businesses to define how signers interact with documents, either sequentially (one after another) or in parallel (simultaneously). For mixed workflows—combining both approaches—proper setup ensures compliance, reduces delays, and streamlines approvals. From a business perspective, mastering this in platforms like DocuSign can optimize contract cycles, particularly in industries like real estate, finance, and HR where multi-party agreements are common.

Comparing eSignature platforms with DocuSign or Adobe Sign?

eSignGlobal delivers a more flexible and cost-effective eSignature solution with global compliance, transparent pricing, and faster onboarding.

👉 Start Free Trial

Configuring Signing Order: Step-by-Step Guide for Mixed Workflows

The Basics of Sequential vs. Parallel Signing

Before diving into mixed configurations, it’s essential to grasp the fundamentals. In sequential signing, each signer must complete their action before the document advances to the next party. This is ideal for linear processes, such as a contract review where legal approval precedes executive sign-off. Parallel signing, on the other hand, enables multiple signers to access and sign the document at the same time, accelerating workflows for non-dependent approvals, like co-signers on a simple NDA.

Mixed workflows blend these: for instance, a sales contract might require sequential signing from the buyer and seller, but parallel input from internal stakeholders like finance and legal. Platforms like DocuSign’s eSignature support this flexibility through intuitive routing rules, ensuring documents aren’t bottlenecked while maintaining audit trails for compliance.

Step 1: Accessing the Envelope Creation Interface

To configure signing order in DocuSign, start by logging into your account and creating a new envelope (DocuSign’s term for a document package). Navigate to the “Send” tab and upload your document. Here, you’ll enter the recipients’ details—names, emails, and roles. DocuSign’s interface, part of its broader Intelligent Agreement Management (IAM) suite, integrates these steps seamlessly with contract lifecycle management (CLM) tools, allowing for automated routing based on predefined templates.

For mixed workflows, identify which signers need sequential progression (e.g., via dependencies) and which can proceed in parallel. DocuSign’s IAM CLM, an advanced module, enhances this by linking signing orders to broader contract automation, including clause extraction and risk analysis, making it suitable for enterprise-scale operations.

Step 2: Setting Up Recipients and Routing

In the “Recipients” section, add all parties. DocuSign allows up to 100 recipients per envelope, with options to group them. For sequential elements:

• Assign roles like “Signer 1,” “Signer 2,” etc., and enable “Sequential Routing” under the advanced options. This locks the document until the prior signer completes their fields.

For parallel branches:

• Select multiple recipients and choose “Parallel Routing.” They receive notifications simultaneously, and the workflow advances once all have signed (or based on custom rules).

To mix them, use “Routing Order” settings. Drag and drop recipients into a visual flowchart. For example, route the document sequentially to Approver A, then branch it in parallel to Reviewers B and C. Once B and C complete, it proceeds sequentially to Final Signer D. This hybrid setup is configured via the “Specify Recipient Routing” dialog, where you toggle between “In Sequence” and “Any Order” for subgroups.

Businesses benefit from this in scenarios like procurement: sequential for vendor negotiation, parallel for internal department reviews. Note that in regions with strict eSignature laws—such as the EU’s eIDAS regulation, which mandates qualified electronic signatures (QES) for high-value contracts—ensure parallel paths include timestamping to preserve legal validity.

Step 3: Assigning Fields and Conditional Logic

Next, place signature fields on the document using DocuSign’s drag-and-drop editor. For mixed orders, apply conditional routing:

• Use “Conditional Fields” in Business Pro or higher plans. For instance, if Signer 1 approves a clause, trigger parallel access for others; otherwise, loop back sequentially.

• Set deadlines and reminders per route to prevent stalls. In IAM CLM, AI-driven logic can auto-adjust orders based on document content, like escalating to parallel if a high-risk term is detected.

Test the workflow in DocuSign’s preview mode to simulate mixed paths. This step is crucial for compliance in the US under ESIGN Act, which requires clear intent and consent records—DocuSign’s audit logs capture every action.

Step 4: Advanced Features for Mixed Workflows

For complexity, leverage DocuSign’s Bulk Send or Web Forms in mixed setups. In Business Pro ($40/user/month annually), integrate signer attachments or payments into parallel branches. API users (via Developer plans starting at $600/year) can programmatically define orders using the Envelopes API, specifying “routingOrder” parameters for sequences (e.g., order=1 for first, order=2 for next) and parallel lists.

Challenges in mixed workflows include managing notifications—parallel signers might overlap, causing confusion. Mitigate with custom emails and access codes. In APAC regions, where eSignature laws vary (e.g., Singapore’s Electronic Transactions Act requires secure delivery), ensure parallel paths support SMS/WhatsApp add-ons ($0.50–$1 per message) for faster regional adoption.

Best Practices and Common Pitfalls

From a commercial viewpoint, mixed signing orders can cut approval times by 40–50%, per industry benchmarks, but misconfigurations lead to 20% rework rates. Always define clear roles, use templates for repeatability, and monitor via dashboards. For global teams, align with local laws: in China, under the Electronic Signature Law, sequential orders may be preferred for evidentiary chains, while parallel suits collaborative B2B.

In summary, DocuSign’s tools make mixed configurations straightforward, balancing speed and security for diverse business needs.

Overview of Key eSignature Platforms

DocuSign: The Enterprise Standard

DocuSign leads the eSignature market with robust tools for signing orders and workflows. Its eSignature plans range from Personal ($10/month) to Business Pro ($40/user/month annually), supporting unlimited envelopes in higher tiers with caps on automation (e.g., 100/year/user). IAM CLM adds AI-powered contract insights, ideal for mixed workflows in regulated sectors. Strengths include seamless integrations (e.g., Salesforce) and global compliance, though APAC latency can affect parallel routing speeds.

Adobe Sign: Versatile Integration Focus

Adobe Sign, part of Adobe Document Cloud, excels in embedding signing into creative workflows. Pricing starts at $10/user/month for individuals, scaling to Enterprise (custom). It handles mixed orders via “Participant Groups” for parallel/sequential routing, with strong Acrobat ties for PDF editing. Compliance covers ESIGN/UETA and eIDAS, but add-ons like SMS delivery incur extra fees. Businesses in design-heavy industries appreciate its conditional logic, though setup can feel less intuitive for non-Adobe users.

eSignGlobal: APAC-Optimized Challenger

eSignGlobal positions itself as a global eSignature provider compliant in 100 mainstream countries, with a strong edge in APAC. The region features fragmented, high-standard, and strictly regulated eSignature landscapes—unlike the framework-based ESIGN/eIDAS in the US/EU, APAC emphasizes “ecosystem-integrated” standards requiring deep hardware/API integrations with government digital identities (G2B). This raises technical barriers far beyond email verification or self-declaration models common in the West. eSignGlobal’s Essential plan ($16.6/month annually, or $299/year) offers unlimited user seats, up to 100 documents for signature, and verification via access codes, delivering high cost-effectiveness on a compliant foundation. It integrates seamlessly with Hong Kong’s iAM Smart and Singapore’s Singpass, enabling efficient mixed workflows. Globally, including in the US and EU, eSignGlobal is pursuing comprehensive competition and replacement strategies against incumbents, often at lower costs without seat fees.

Looking for a smarter alternative to DocuSign?

eSignGlobal delivers a more flexible and cost-effective eSignature solution with global compliance, transparent pricing, and faster onboarding.

👉 Start Free Trial

HelloSign (Dropbox Sign): User-Friendly Option

HelloSign, now Dropbox Sign, focuses on simplicity with plans from Free (3 documents/month) to Premium ($15/user/month). It supports basic sequential/parallel orders via recipient sequencing, integrated with Dropbox for storage. Ideal for SMBs, it complies with ESIGN/eIDAS but lacks advanced IAM features, making complex mixed workflows less scalable.

Comparative Analysis of eSignature Platforms

This table highlights neutral trade-offs: DocuSign for depth, Adobe for integration, eSignGlobal for regional efficiency, and HelloSign for accessibility.

Business Implications and Final Thoughts

Configuring signing orders in mixed workflows demands tools that balance flexibility with compliance, impacting operational efficiency across borders. While DocuSign sets a high bar, alternatives like eSignGlobal offer viable options for regional compliance needs.