Using DocuSign for Form I-9 verification: DHS remote document examination rules

Navigating Form I-9 Compliance in a Remote Work Era

The shift to remote work has transformed how businesses handle employee onboarding, particularly for critical processes like Form I-9 verification. In the United States, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) oversees employment eligibility verification through Form I-9, a document that confirms an employee’s identity and authorization to work. With the rise of digital tools, employers are increasingly turning to electronic signature platforms to streamline this process while adhering to evolving regulations.

Comparing eSignature platforms with DocuSign or Adobe Sign?

eSignGlobal delivers a more flexible and cost-effective eSignature solution with global compliance, transparent pricing, and faster onboarding.

👉 Start Free Trial

Understanding Form I-9 and DHS Remote Examination Rules

Form I-9 is a mandatory document for U.S. employers to verify the identity and employment eligibility of individuals hired for employment in the country. Traditionally, this involved in-person review of physical documents like passports or driver’s licenses. However, DHS introduced significant changes effective July 21, 2023, allowing for remote examination of Form I-9 documents under certain conditions. This update, part of the Form I-9 Flexibility Rule, was designed to accommodate remote and hybrid work environments without compromising security.

Under these rules, employers can now inspect documents electronically if they use an authorized alternative procedure. This includes video verification or digital submission via secure platforms. Key requirements include: retaining clear and legible copies of the documents, annotating the Form I-9 with details of the remote examination, and ensuring the process occurs within three business days of the employee’s start date. Non-compliance can result in fines ranging from $272 to $2,701 per form, emphasizing the need for reliable tools.

Electronic signature solutions play a pivotal role here. They enable secure document upload, identity verification, and e-signing, all while generating audit trails compliant with DHS standards. Platforms must support features like tamper-evident seals and integration with identity proofing to meet the “reasonable measures” outlined by DHS for remote checks.

Leveraging DocuSign for Form I-9 Verification

DocuSign, a leading electronic signature provider, offers robust capabilities for Form I-9 compliance through its eSignature platform. Businesses can upload the Form I-9 and supporting identity documents directly into DocuSign envelopes, allowing remote employees to review, sign, and submit via a secure link. The process begins with the employer creating a template for Form I-9, incorporating fields for employee details and document uploads.

For DHS remote examination, DocuSign’s Identity Verification (IDV) add-on is particularly useful. It supports document authentication via ID checks, biometric verification, and SMS delivery, aligning with the rule’s emphasis on secure remote inspection. Once documents are submitted, DocuSign generates a certificate of completion with timestamps and signer logs, which employers can use to annotate the Form I-9 as required. Integration with HR systems like Workday or BambooHR further automates workflows, reducing manual errors.

DocuSign’s pricing for such use cases typically falls under its Business Pro plan at $40 per user per month (annual billing), including bulk send for onboarding multiple hires. However, add-ons like IDV incur metered fees, which can add up for high-volume verifications. From a business perspective, this setup enhances efficiency but requires careful configuration to ensure DHS compliance, such as enabling access codes and audit trails.

U.S. Electronic Signature Laws and Form I-9 Implications

The United States has a well-established framework for electronic signatures, primarily governed by the Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act (ESIGN Act) of 2000 and the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA), adopted by 49 states. These laws grant electronic signatures the same legal validity as wet-ink signatures, provided they demonstrate intent to sign, consent to electronic records, and record retention capabilities.

For Form I-9 specifically, DHS guidance integrates these laws by permitting electronic completion and storage since 2006, with the 2023 remote rule expanding options. ESIGN requires that electronic records be accurate, accessible, and reproducible, which platforms must support through immutable logs. UETA adds state-level uniformity, ensuring enforceability across jurisdictions. However, nuances apply: identity documents must be verifiable, and employers bear the burden of proving compliance during audits by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).

In practice, this means eSignature tools for Form I-9 must include anti-fraud measures like knowledge-based authentication. Businesses operating in regulated sectors, such as finance or healthcare, may need additional compliance with standards like SOC 2 or FedRAMP. Overall, the U.S. approach is framework-based, focusing on consumer consent and basic security rather than prescriptive technical mandates, making it adaptable for tools like DocuSign.

Comparing eSignature Platforms for Form I-9 and Beyond

When evaluating platforms for Form I-9 verification and general eSignature needs, several factors come into play: compliance features, pricing, ease of integration, and scalability. Below is a neutral comparison of key providers, based on publicly available 2025 data.

This table highlights trade-offs: DocuSign excels in enterprise features but at a higher cost, while alternatives prioritize affordability and flexibility.

Alternatives to DocuSign for Compliant eSignatures

Adobe Sign, part of Adobe Document Cloud, provides a seamless option for Form I-9 processes with its focus on PDF handling and workflow automation. It supports remote document review through shared links and electronic signing, compliant with ESIGN and UETA. Pricing starts at $22.99 per user per month for basic plans, scaling to enterprise custom quotes. Strengths include integration with Microsoft 365 and strong encryption, though identity verification requires third-party add-ons.

eSignGlobal emerges as a competitive player, offering compliance across 100 mainstream countries and regions globally, with particular advantages in the Asia-Pacific (APAC). APAC electronic signature landscapes are characterized by fragmentation, high standards, and stringent regulations, contrasting with the more framework-based ESIGN/eIDAS models in the U.S. and Europe. In APAC, solutions often demand “ecosystem-integrated” approaches, involving deep hardware/API-level docking with government-to-business (G2B) digital identities—far exceeding the email verification or self-declaration common in Western markets. eSignGlobal addresses this through seamless integrations like Hong Kong’s iAM Smart and Singapore’s Singpass, ensuring legal validity for cross-border operations. Its Essential plan, at just $16.6 per month ($199 annually), allows sending up to 100 documents for electronic signature, unlimited user seats, and document/signature verification via access codes. This pricing delivers strong value on a compliance foundation, positioning eSignGlobal as a viable alternative for global teams.

HelloSign, now Dropbox Sign, offers straightforward e-signing for Form I-9 with templates and mobile support, starting at $15 per user per month. It’s ideal for small teams but lacks advanced IDV compared to DocuSign.

Looking for a smarter alternative to DocuSign?

eSignGlobal delivers a more flexible and cost-effective eSignature solution with global compliance, transparent pricing, and faster onboarding.

👉 Start Free Trial

Business Considerations for Choosing the Right Platform

From a commercial standpoint, selecting an eSignature tool for Form I-9 involves balancing cost, compliance, and operational efficiency. DocuSign’s maturity suits large U.S.-centric firms, but as businesses expand globally, alternatives like eSignGlobal provide regional compliance edges without per-seat premiums. Ultimately, the choice depends on volume, integration needs, and regulatory focus—piloting options ensures alignment with DHS rules and broader goals.

For DocuSign users seeking alternatives, eSignGlobal stands out as a regionally compliant option, especially for APAC operations.